Jakarta — Amidst global pressures to transition toward sustainable energy sources and reduce carbon emissions, the Indonesian government faced mounting scrutiny regarding its heavy reliance on fossil fuels. In a decisive move to address the nation’s long-term energy security, then-Coordinating Minister for Maritime Affairs and Resources, Rizal Ramli, strongly emphasized the urgent need for comprehensive energy diversification. Speaking at his office in Jakarta on Monday, November 9, 2015, Ramli convened high-level discussions aimed at accelerating the development of alternative energy products, steering the archipelago away from its historical dependence on coal.
The policy dialogue underscored a persistent paradox within Indonesia’s energy sector: while political speeches, national development plans, and international forums frequently championed the transition to renewable energy, the actual implementation on the ground lagged significantly behind rhetoric. Despite possessing some of the world’s most abundant renewable energy reserves—ranging from geothermal and hydropower to solar and biomass—the Southeast Asian economic powerhouse struggled to translate its natural potential into operational wattage. The discussions spearheaded by Ramli sought to diagnose the structural bottlenecks inhibiting the growth of green energy and to formulate actionable incentives to attract private sector participation.
The Reality of Slow Transition and Infrastructural Gaps
For decades, Indonesia’s power grid has been heavily anchored on coal-fired power plants. This reliance was largely driven by the country’s vast domestic coal reserves, particularly in Sumatra and Kalimantan, which offered cheap, reliable, and easily accessible baseload electricity to fuel rapid industrialization and meet surging urban demand. However, this coal-centric strategy created an entrenched ecosystem that inadvertently sidelined alternative energy development.
During the November 2015 deliberations, government officials and energy experts confronted the stark reality on the ground: despite years of strategic planning, very few renewable energy installations had successfully moved from the drawing board to commercial operation. Hydroelectric power projects faced lengthy permitting processes and environmental assessments, while geothermal exploration remained sluggish despite Indonesia sitting squarely on the Pacific Ring of Fire, holding roughly 40 percent of the world’s geothermal potential.
Ramli pointedly questioned the underlying causes of this sluggish progress. While bureaucratic red tape and complex land acquisition procedures were frequently cited as historical deterrents, the core of the problem pointed toward a more fundamental economic deterrent: unattractive pricing structures for independent power producers (IPPs).
The Economics of Investment: Pricing and Regulatory Hurdles
At the heart of the debate was the financial viability of renewable energy projects for private investors. In a market where coal-fired electricity benefited from long-term government subsidies, price caps, and guaranteed purchase agreements, renewable alternatives often struggled to compete on a level playing field. Geothermal energy and solar power require substantial capital expenditure (CapEx) upfront, with lengthy exploration phases that carry inherent geological and financial risks.
Ramli highlighted that unless the government introduced more compelling and economically viable pricing models—often referred to as feed-in tariffs or attractive power purchase agreements (PPAs)—private investors would continue to steer clear of Indonesia’s renewable sector. "We suspect that the pricing is simply not attractive enough," Ramli stated during the briefing. "We need to formulate a pricing scheme that genuinely incentivizes investors to pour capital into geothermal and solar energy."
The appeal to market logic was clear: private capital will naturally flow toward sectors offering risk-adjusted returns that justify the initial outlay. By maintaining rigid or uncompetitive electricity purchase tariffs set by the state electricity company, Perusahaan Listrik Negara (PLN), the government inadvertently choked off the capital inflows necessary to scale up green infrastructure.
Historical Context and Policy Evolution in 2015
The late 2015 policy discussions occurred against a backdrop of shifting global climate commitments. The international community was gearing up for the landmark COP 21 Paris Climate Conference, scheduled for December 2015, where developing nations like Indonesia were expected to outline concrete nationally determined contributions (NDCs) to curb greenhouse gas emissions.
Domestically, the administration of President Joko Widodo had set an ambitious target of achieving 35,000 megawatts (MW) of new power generation capacity by 2019 to prevent rolling blackouts and power industrial expansion. However, the initial blueprint of the 35,000 MW program relied overwhelmingly on coal-fired power plants, drawing sharp criticism from environmental organizations, climate scientists, and economists who warned of severe lock-in effects and long-term environmental degradation.
Ramli’s intervention in November 2015 represented a critical internal pushback within the cabinet against business-as-usual energy planning. As the Coordinating Minister for Maritime Affairs and Resources, Ramli’s portfolio intersected with natural resource extraction, environmental management, and maritime logistics, giving him a unique vantage point to critique the ecological and economic tolls of unmitigated coal dependence.
Broader Implications and Long-Term Economic Impact
The push for energy diversification carries profound implications for Indonesia’s macroeconomic stability, fiscal health, and geopolitical standing. A comprehensive transition away from coal involves navigating several interconnected economic vectors:
1. Fiscal Sustainability and Subsidies
For years, fossil fuel subsidies placed a heavy burden on the state budget. While coal was cheaper to burn domestically, exporting higher-quality coal remained a major source of state revenue. However, relying entirely on a finite commodity exposed the national economy to global commodity price shocks. Diversifying into domestic renewables promised a more insulated, self-sustaining energy ecosystem.
2. Environmental and Health Costs
The externalized costs of coal combustion—ranging from local air pollution and respiratory illnesses in industrial clusters to global carbon emissions—were rarely factored into traditional economic cost-benefit analyses. Transitioning toward geothermal and solar power offered substantial public health co-benefits, reducing healthcare expenditures associated with particulate matter and sulfur dioxide emissions.
3. Investor Sentiment and Global Capital
By 2015, global institutional investors and international development banks were beginning to divest from coal projects in alignment with environmental, social, and governance (ESG) mandates. If Indonesia wished to attract foreign direct investment (FDI) for its infrastructure development, modernizing its regulatory framework to welcome green energy financing was no longer optional—it was an economic imperative. Failing to offer attractive pricing for renewables risked isolating Indonesia from the rapidly growing global pool of green capital.
Conclusion and Subsequent Path Forward
The dialogue initiated by Rizal Ramli in late 2015 served as an important wake-up call for policymakers, regulators, and state-owned enterprises in Indonesia. It underscored the reality that declaring political intentions to embrace renewable energy is insufficient without structural, regulatory, and pricing reforms that make green investments financially attractive.
While the transition from a coal-dependent grid to a diversified, renewable-heavy energy architecture presented immense logistical challenges, the discussions laid foundational groundwork for future policy adjustments. Over subsequent years, Indonesia gradually introduced more supportive regulatory frameworks, improved feed-in tariffs for geothermal and solar projects, and began the delicate task of balancing energy affordability, security, and sustainability for its population of over 250 million people.



