Home Health & Wellness Sudirman Said Merasa Kecolongan Soal Direksi Baru PLN

Sudirman Said Merasa Kecolongan Soal Direksi Baru PLN

by Suro Senen

The governance of state-owned enterprises (SOEs) in Indonesia has long been a subject of intense public scrutiny, balancing the delicate lines between ministerial oversight, corporate autonomy, and strategic alignment. A striking example of this intricate dynamic came to light in November 2015, when the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources (ESDM) voiced public disappointment regarding administrative procedures within PT PLN (Persero), the country’s state-owned electricity monopoly. The crux of the friction centered on the unilateral appointment of four new members to PLN’s board of directors, a move executed without waiting for the inauguration of a new President Commissioner, or Komisaris Utama (Komut), who was already slated to take office.

This administrative misstep prompted sharp critiques from the highest levels of the energy ministry, exposing underlying coordination challenges within the Indonesian government’s handling of vital energy infrastructure entities. The incident served as a focal point for discussions concerning corporate governance, institutional communication, and the boundaries of authority between various state bodies.

Background Context: The Strategic Role of PLN and Ministerial Oversight

PT PLN (Persero) remains the backbone of Indonesia’s power sector, holding a strategic monopoly over electricity generation, transmission, and distribution across the archipelago. Given its critical role in fueling economic growth, supporting national development, and executing ambitious energy projects—such as the 35,000-megawatt power plant electrification program—the leadership configuration of PLN is a matter of paramount national interest.

Management changes within such a vital enterprise traditionally require robust coordination and alignment among key stakeholders, primarily the Ministry of State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs) as the shareholder representative, the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources as the sector regulator and policy formulator, and the internal board of commissioners charged with supervisory duties.

In late 2015, the energy landscape in Indonesia was undergoing significant shifts. The government was pushing forward with aggressive infrastructure targets while attempting to streamline bureaucratic red tape. However, administrative coordination occasionally lagged behind executive ambitions, leading to procedural oversights that could signal friction or a lack of synchronization among key government ministries.

The Chronology of Events

The controversy unfolded in early November 2015 at the State Palace in Jakarta. PT PLN (Persero) proceeded with the formal inauguration and appointment of four new members to its board of directors. While corporate boards possess the structural autonomy to execute operational decisions, the timing of this specific appointments drew immediate concern from the energy sector’s supervisory bodies.

The decision to install the new directors was finalized and executed just as a new President Commissioner for the utility company had been chosen but not yet officially inaugurated. Although the outgoing board of commissioners remained technically active, standard corporate courtesy and governance best practices dictate that incoming executive leadership should ideally be vetted or at least consulted in tandem with incoming supervisory leadership to ensure a cohesive strategic vision from day one.

Upon learning of the finalized appointments, the then-Minister of Energy and Mineral Resources, Sudirman Said, addressed the media at the State Palace on Wednesday, November 4, 2015. He openly expressed his surprise and sense of being bypassed—colloquially termed feeling kecolongan—regarding the swift actions taken by the electricity giant’s leadership.

Ministerial Reactions and the Principle of Corporate Governance

Speaking to journalists, Minister Sudirman Said acknowledged that from a strictly legal and procedural standpoint, PLN was not explicitly prohibited from appointing directors while awaiting the official installment of a new President Commissioner. Existing commissioners were still holding office, which technically fulfilled the quorum requirements for administrative actions.

However, Sudirman emphasized that legality does not always equate to optimal corporate governance. He argued that the ethical and practical dimensions of corporate management demanded a more patient approach. Given that the appointment of the new President Commissioner was already common knowledge and imminent, the prudent course of action for PLN’s President Director and executive team would have been to wait for the incoming commissioner to be officially sworn in and subsequently initiate consultations.

"Actually, there is no strict obligation to wait for the Komut [President Commissioner], because the existing commissioners are still there. But customarily, since they already knew there would be a new Komut, the President Director should have waited for the new Komut to be inaugurated and then consulted," Sudirman stated firmly at the State Palace.

Furthermore, Sudirman underscored the vital role that internal boards of commissioners play in the selection and vetting process of state-owned enterprise directors. In a healthy corporate structure, the board of directors should not operate in a vacuum. The inclusion of commissioners in strategic personnel decisions ensures that oversight mechanisms remain robust and aligned with overall corporate policy.

"To my knowledge, there is a process where the proposal of directors goes through discussions with the commissioners," Sudirman added, highlighting what he perceived as a departure from standard checks and balances.

Awaiting Clarification from the Ministry of SOEs

At the time, the Ministry of State-Owned Enterprises (SOEs), led by Minister Rini Soemarno, held the primary authority over structural appointments within state-owned companies. The sudden announcement and execution of the directorate changes without prior alignment with the ESDM ministry highlighted potential gaps in inter-ministerial communication.

Addressing reporters regarding the ultimate background and rationale behind the swift appointments, Sudirman indicated that he would seek direct clarification from Minister Rini Soemarno upon her return from official duties.

"I don’t know. That’s why I’m waiting for Ibu Rini to return, to ask about the background," Sudirman remarked, pointing to the necessity of inter-ministerial dialogue to resolve coordination discrepancies.

Implications for State-Owned Enterprise Governance

The public airing of this coordination hiccup carried several broader implications for the management of Indonesia’s state-owned enterprises:

  1. Inter-Agency Synergy: The incident underscored the critical need for seamless communication between sector-specific regulators (such as the Ministry of ESDM) and shareholder representatives (the Ministry of SOEs). When major decisions regarding crucial utilities like PLN are made without synchronized timing, it risks projecting an image of institutional disarray.
  2. Strengthening Corporate Etiquette: Beyond statutory compliance, adherence to corporate etiquette—such as consulting incoming oversight leadership—reinforces trust and stability within management ranks. For a company undertaking massive national projects, internal stability and clear chains of command are indispensable.
  3. Strengthening the Supervisory Function: The commentary from the energy ministry served as a reminder that the board of commissioners must be treated as an active, integral part of corporate governance rather than a passive rubber-stamp body. Ensuring that commissioners are consulted on executive appointments protects the long-term strategic interests of the state.

Conclusion

The unexpected appointment of four new directors at PT PLN (Persero) in November 2015, executed just ahead of the inauguration of a new President Commissioner, captured a classic governance dilemma within Indonesia’s public sector. While operating within technical legal boundaries, the move tested the limits of inter-agency coordination and corporate etiquette. By publicly addressing the oversight, Minister Sudirman Said brought vital attention to the principles of transparency, consultation, and institutional synergy, setting a benchmark for how state-owned enterprises ought to navigate leadership transitions in the pursuit of national energy objectives.

You may also like