Home Health & Wellness Tolak Pembangkit Listrik Nuklir, Pemerintah Dinilai Bermental Tempe

Tolak Pembangkit Listrik Nuklir, Pemerintah Dinilai Bermental Tempe

by Laily UPN

JAKARTA — The ongoing debate over Indonesia’s energy future reached a critical juncture in November 2015, as energy experts and policymakers clashed over the inclusion of nuclear power in the nation’s ambitious infrastructure roadmap. At the heart of the controversy was the government’s unwavering stance to exclude Nuclear Power Plants (PLTN) from the landmark 35,000-megawatt (MW) electrification megaproject. While the administration maintained that nuclear energy remained a remote option due to safety concerns and public acceptance challenges, energy analysts severely criticized the policy, characterizing the reluctance as an aversion to technological advancement and a lack of strategic foresight in securing the country’s long-term energy independence.

The controversy erupted as the Ministry of Energy and Mineral Resources accelerated its efforts to address chronic electricity shortages and low electrification ratios across the archipelago. The 35,000 MW program, launched earlier in the administration of President Joko Widodo, was designed to drive economic growth, bridge development disparities between Java and the outer islands, and power industrial expansion. However, the energy mix planned for the megaproject leaned heavily on coal, natural gas, and emerging renewable sources such as hydro, geothermal, and solar, while explicitly keeping nuclear energy off the immediate development agenda.

Expert Criticisms and Technological Resistance

Weighing in on the government’s policy, prominent energy expert from the University of Indonesia, Iwa Garniwa, expressed profound disappointment over the exclusion of nuclear technology. In an interview in Jakarta, Garniwa argued that deliberately bypassing nuclear power was equivalent to retreating from global technological evolution at a time when numerous industrialized and developing nations were successfully harnessing nuclear energy to meet surging baseload electricity demands reliably and with low carbon emissions.

"I am saddened to hear that. We are resistant to technology," Garniwa stated. "We are actively distancing ourselves from a nuclear technology that is currently being widely and safely utilized by other nations around the world."

Garniwa pointed out that achieving an energy capacity of 35,000 MW required a diversified portfolio of primary energy sources. Relying solely on conventional fossil fuels or intermittent renewables without a stable baseload provider like nuclear could expose the national grid to vulnerabilities. He specifically criticized the government’s categorization of nuclear power as an absolute "last resort" option, questioning the logical parameters of such a policy framework.

"What does ‘last resort’ even mean in this context? Does it mean we only turn to nuclear energy when water and solar natural resources are completely exhausted? By that time, we will already be ruined," he added, emphasizing the urgency of proactive energy planning.

Addressing concerns regarding Indonesia’s readiness to operate nuclear facilities—often cited by officials as a primary bottleneck—Garniwa suggested that technological capability and human resource capacity could be developed incrementally through smaller-scale experimental or commercial reactors coupled with rigorous maintenance protocols. Dismissing the nation’s capacity outright, he argued, reflected a defeatist mindset that undermines national potential. "Build a small one first, but maintain it properly. We act like tempe—cowering away from technology that is already operational abroad. That is a weak mindset," Garniwa concluded.

Background Context: The 35,000 MW Megaproject and Energy Diversification

The 35,000 MW electrification program represented one of the most aggressive infrastructure initiatives in modern Indonesian history. Initiated to overcome chronic power deficits that frequently triggered rolling blackouts outside Java, the program aimed to boost the national electrification ratio from around 84 percent in 2014 to over 96 percent by the end of the decade.

Tolak Pembangkit Listrik Nuklir, Pemerintah Dinilai Bermental Tempe : Okezone Economy

State-owned electricity enterprise PT Perusahaan Listrik Negara (PLN) was tasked with spearheading the massive capacity addition, collaborating with Independent Power Producers (IPPs) to construct dozens of new power plants. While the blueprint initially prioritized coal-fired power plants (CFPPs) due to their low cost and abundant domestic supply, environmental pressures and international climate commitments gradually compelled policymakers to reevaluate the energy mix.

Despite the global discourse on decarbonization, nuclear energy remained a polarizing topic within Indonesian policy circles. Proposals to construct a nuclear power plant on the Muria Peninsula in Central Java had surfaced and stalled multiple times over preceding decades. Public apprehension, amplified by memories of global nuclear disasters such as Chernobyl in 1986 and Fukushima Daiichi in 2011, created a formidable political barrier. Consequently, successive administrations exercised extreme caution, treating nuclear energy as a theoretical option for the distant future rather than an immediate solution for the 35,000 MW milestone.

Chronology of Nuclear Energy Policy Debates in Indonesia

The friction between technocratic ambition and political caution regarding nuclear energy has a long history in Southeast Asia’s largest economy:

  • 1950s–1960s: Indonesia establishes the National Atomic Energy Agency (BATAN), laying the groundwork for nuclear research, isotope applications, and preliminary studies on nuclear power generation.
  • 1990s: Feasibility studies identify the Muria Peninsula as a viable location for Indonesia’s first commercial nuclear power plant, though the project is shelved following the Asian Financial Crisis and strong local opposition.
  • 2006–2009: The government revives discussions under the National Energy Policy, targeting the operation of the first nuclear reactor by 2016. Preparatory studies continue, but safety concerns and shifting political priorities stall execution.
  • 2014–2015: The new administration launches the 35,000 MW electrification program. Energy officials officially designate nuclear power as a "last resort" or long-term option, effectively excluding it from the immediate medium-term infrastructure rollout, sparking backlash from academic and technical communities like Iwa Garniwa.
  • Post-2015 Era: The debate persists as Indonesia grapples with net-zero emission targets, balancing the phase-out of coal with the necessity of stable baseload power, keeping the nuclear debate perpetually relevant.

Implications for National Energy Security and Climate Targets

The debate over nuclear power carries profound implications for Indonesia’s long-term economic competitiveness, energy security, and environmental commitments. As an archipelago experiencing rapid industrialization, urbanization, and population growth, Indonesia’s electricity demand is projected to scale exponentially in the coming decades.

Proponents of nuclear energy argue that it offers unmatched advantages as a high-density, zero-emission baseload power source. Unlike solar and wind energy, which depend on weather conditions and require substantial energy storage solutions, nuclear plants can operate continuously at high capacity factors for extended periods. Furthermore, modern small modular reactors (SMRs) present enhanced safety features and lower initial capital costs compared to traditional gigawatt-scale reactors, making them potentially suitable for archipelagic distribution.

Conversely, opponents and cautious policymakers highlight the immense financial capital required, the lengthy regulatory and construction timelines—often spanning a decade or more—and the unresolved challenges concerning radioactive waste management and nuclear non-proliferation. Additionally, Indonesia’s geographical position along the Pacific Ring of Fire exposes the region to frequent seismic activity and tsunamis, necessitating stringent site selection and engineering safeguards that escalate project costs.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The criticism voiced by energy experts in late 2015 underscored a deeper tension within Indonesia’s energy governance: the friction between immediate electrification targets driven by fossil fuels and the strategic imperative to embrace advanced, low-carbon technologies for the future. While the government ultimately prioritized rapid capacity addition through conventional means to meet immediate socio-economic demands, the underlying debate regarding the viability of nuclear energy has refused to dissipate.

As Indonesia continues to refine its Nationally Determined Contributions (NDCs) under global climate frameworks and moves toward eventual coal phase-out, policymakers face the enduring challenge of balancing energy affordability, reliability, and environmental sustainability. Whether nuclear power will eventually transition from a "last resort" to an active pillar of the national energy mix remains one of the most consequential strategic decisions facing the nation’s energy sector in the twenty-first century.

You may also like